Coroners attempt to limit access to


Safe guidelines for school chemical storage and security

Safe guildelines for school chemical storage and security

 Jan Murphy recently authored a report in The Patriot of Central PA that re-counted an effort by Pennsylvania Coroner Association to limit access to autopsy reports to cause and manner of death of the victim.

Proponents of the bill dismiss arguments that public health threats wouldn’t be disclosed.They say most coroners around the state bring issues of community concern to the public’s attention when they notice a trend, such as deaths related to the synthetic drug known as bath salts.” writes Jan Murphy.

However, at issue is the family who anguished for years due to the denial of information regarding the death of their loved one.

  • How did they die? 
  • What really caused a sudden, unattended death? 
  • Is the death from an illness that could be hereditary? 
  • Was the death really murder?

These questions and more haunt the family after a tragic death incident.

“Two men were found dead in their Hollidaysburg apartment in September 2009.

But it wasn’t until five months later, when the Blair County coroner released her annual report, that the public learned the causes of death were prescription-drug overdoses. That report by Coroner Patricia Ross helped sharpen the focus on a growing problem of prescription-drug abuse in that county.

Long delays in the release of information about community problems could become more commonplace, said Deb Musselman, the government affairs director for the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association.”

An editorial opinion in Post-Gazette, published March 29, 2012 under the title Threat of secrecy: Pennsylvania coroners’ records must stay public clearly defines the injustice sought by the Pennsylvania Coroner Association who, according to the opinion piece are arguing for the ability to keep public records from “inspection by the public and media”.

“Coroners do have discretion to release more information but, if they don’t want to, they no longer would have to.  Coroners are not elected to be grief counselors, though, and their (coroners) job is not to shield family members from potentially embarrassing or unsettling details when a loved one dies, especially by withholding important information from the public.

If the bill (House bill 2477) becomes law, it also would prevent Pennsylvanians from looking over their coroners’ shoulders to make sure they are properly conducting the public’s business.”

Fortunately, governor at the time, Governor Rendell, did not sign the bill and demonstrated that he “still believes in strong citizen access to public records”.

Another opinion, Ruling may return autopsy issue to Pa. Legislature, by Mark Scolford of the Associated Press argues that privacy is important in  the case of NASCAR driver Dale Earnhardt who was killed in a crash during a Daytona 500 race in 2001.  The press was scrambling for the photos of Earnhardt following the autopsy.  The family asked the records remain private due to concerns that only the gory photos would be published throughout the world as ‘news’. 

“Privacy issues related to autopsies arose nationally after the death of NASCAR driver Dale Earnhardt during the 2001 Daytona 500. There were questions about whether his safety equipment had been inadequate, and news organizations sought his autopsy photos.”

Earnhardt’s family requested Florida legislature rule on the case.

“Earnhardt’s widow fought the release, (of photos) and the Florida Legislature subsequently passed a law that precluded public inspection of autopsy photos.”

Understandably there are times when discretion must be used.  Earnhardt’s family could have asked a judge to rule on the issue and seal the record.  But this would and should not preclude the family from receiving the autopsy record.

We have written extensively in this blog and posted documents at http://www.denied-justice.com supporting the self-serving actions of Montgomery County corner Walter Hofman who refuses to release results from additional testing he promised in August 2011 from the autopsy of Raymond Marc Zachry who suddenly collapsed and died in Souderton. Pennsylvania on September 25, 2007.  The family has spent multiple thousands of dollars on lawyers and experts, still Hofman refuses to cooperate or explain the redacted and altered toxicology reports that are posted at http://www.denied-justice.com

A ruling allowing coroners and medical examiners to hide their work from public scrutiny there would be no recourse for the innocent who were wrongly convicted, the guilty that are allowed freedom to continue their criminal acts without discovery. It would seem encouragement of family input would be more relevent in death investigations.  Who knows the victim better than the parents, siblings and in some cases spouse?

Your opinion is welcome and encouraged in the comment section.

6 responses to this post.

  1. Keep up the great work and thank you for mentioning my blog. I have not had much computer time this week to get caught up with saying “Thank you”

    Like

    Reply

    • I do appreciate your input into this cause. It is so important – many people have sent messages to me ans asked for help that I must keep the pressure on for the families that are hurting and can’t access information of their loved one cause and manner of death.

      Thank you for following and commenting on this sugject.

      Like

      Reply

  2. What a brave fight you are fighting! I just watched the Ken Lang documentary, again, and I am mortified at the lack of action and justice! How dreadful for you!!! Hugs and warm wishes dear friend.

    Like

    Reply

  3. I nominated your blog for Most Influential Blogs of 2012.If you want to accept, please visit this link http://cristimoise.wordpress.com/2013/03/06/most-influential-blogs-of-2012/
    Congrats !

    Like

    Reply

    • Thank you so much Cristi. You certainly deserve this award since your blog is definately influential in my life. I always enjoy your blog posts.I will have it posted quickly.

      Like

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

ultimatemindsettoday

A great WordPress.com site

SMALLGOVREPORT

Always question the premise

Parenting Abused Children: Hope, Healing & Insight

Information, Links, Inspiration on Child Abuse, Domestic Violence and Healing

PRESS REPOST (ER)

FOR YOUR FAVOURITE WORDPRESS REPOST!!!

The Matter of Life and Death

Life is real! Life is earnest! And, the grave is not it's goal

RetiredAndAngry

If You Like My Blog Tell Your Followers, If Not Tell Me

National Corrections Oversight Coalition Reg'd OJP DOJ DHS Intelligence for Corrections

Investigating Offender Abuse, In Jails, Prisons, Juvenile, Immigration Corrections Facilities In The United States, "ZERO TOLERAsNCE"

Deathly Dames Inc.

an education in diabolical deeds

Where Words Daily Come Alive

A Word Press Blog Which Will Make You Smile

The Poet's Crafts

Life in rhyme - rhyme in life

Boomerang Zone

the score is oogy to boogy

Samuel Snodgrass's Sentimental Sentiments

Wistfulness and Heartache in Poetry and Prose

The Müscleheaded Blog

"Nothing Exceeds Like Superfluous Jejunity "

ann johnson-murphree

Artist, Writer of Confessional Free Verse Poetry and Fiction

EBMSI Group

The Link Between Law & Medicine

Forensic Scientist

Forensic Science and Expert Witnesses

ROBIN POSTELL

The people, places and things I want to share with the world

KENDRICK JOHNSON: The Boy Who Never Came Home

Collection of Images, Stories, Interviews, Commentary, Rumors, Speculation and Photographs

curious57's Blog

police corruption, police brutality, police coverup

Kindness Blog

Kindness Images, Videos, True Life Stories, Quotes, Personal Reflections and Meditations.

Legionwriter

"...The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness can never extinguish it."

FORENSICS and LAW in FOCUS @ CSIDDS | News and Trends

by Mike Bowers - CSI science, law and experts

Never Quite Broken

What you did not build up, you cannot tear down.

The ancient eavesdropper

Nature's nuances in a nutshell

Walking with the Alligators

Speaking for those with no voice~

SayVan Photography

The site is all about this and that and of course whatever else I can think of..with a view to some photography

Writer's notebook

Creative impulsive disorder

tutorials4view

Watch free tutorials in Full HD (1080p) quality video tutorials, sorted by subjects, like: Photoshop, Gimp, Facebook, Torrents, Windows 7, Windows 8, Windows 8.1, Viruses and malware removal ( like ask,com, vqo6, Babylon ) and more and more.. If you like our tutorials and guided, please SUBSCRIBE to out channel at: http://www.youtube.com/user/ShaiSoft - tutorials4view.

The Wine Wankers

G’day, you’re at the best wine blog ever! We're all about wine; without the wankery.

Views From A Small Island

A photographic record of the everyday and the not so everyday life around the UK.

I Digress!

Ever heard that saying, she's all over the place? Well, that pretty much also sums up this blog. It's all over the place. :-)

Inspirational Quotes | Motivational Blog | Images | Pictures

Quotes For Kids | Success Quotes | Bob Marley Quotes

Madeline Scribes

Writing about the human condition and learning to laugh about it

The Fifth Column

"News and views from around the world"

This Labyrinth I Roam

The Great Affair Is To Keep Moving

AshiAkira's Blog

Just another WordPress.com site

cnhFaith.me

Inspiration, Motivation, and Spirituality

It Is What It Is

Dr. Rex .... Blogging for change.

whatcherylsaid...

People were created to be loved, things were created to be used. The reason the world is in chaos, is because things are being loved, and people are being used.

Your Dog Wouldn't Like It

This Site Is Banned In Iran. Supajohnny & Teddybear (the Dog) are :- pro-Israel, Nationalist, Love England, Israel & USA, hate liberal/progressives

My Bright Shining Star

This is a blog about my experience and feelings over the suicide of my 23 year old daughter Kaitlyn on 4-11-13

The Voice Of The Prophetic Report

A topnotch WordPress.com site

%d bloggers like this: